Cremo

I picked up the Cooling Shave Cream that comes in a squeeze-tube, and I have to say that the menthol effect is quite strong, so much so that the effect lasts a while after your shave, practically negating the need for post-shave balms.  Cremo also sells tubs of cream that is formulated for use with its Vie-Long horse hair brush, and the stuff lathers typically well for the price.